I was born where palm trees sway, but the Windy City brought me my first fame. When our nation called, Michelle and I headed to DC. Who am I?

Welcome to a bi-weekly feature where we learn more about members of St. John's through the fast-paced game "This Or That"? Batting leadoff is Pastor John Pawloski:

Cats or Dogs?
Spring or Fall?
Pepperoni or Bacon?
Cardinals or Battlehawks?
Matthew or Luke?
Apple or Samsung?
Coleslaw or Baked Beans?
English Lit or Creative Writing?
Beach or Mountain?
Job or Jonah?

Click to see the answers!